Steven Johnston took his flirtatious on-screen personality a bit too far when he made a ridiculous comment about 90 Day Fiancé: The Other Way co-star Evelin Villegas during the Tell-All. The reunion episode will be an eyeopener of sorts for Steven’s cast members when he openly admits to chatting with nine women at once after being married to Russian girl Alina and saying that he wants a threesome, which Aline has known about all along, though its unclear whether or not threesomes outside of marriage are blessed by the Church of Latter Day Saints. The episode will also feature a surprise guest, Steven’s ex-girlfriend Vanessa who he’s also cheated on. However, before all of that happened, Steven made Evelin extremely uncomfortable with what he said about her outfit.
As always, Steven blames his desire to talk dirty on him having a “lot of sexual energy” and that he’s looking for an outlet so he wouldn’t have to “repress these urges.” Steven confesses during the Tell-All that he did, in fact, share the selfie with him talking lewdly about his long tongue that had recently surfaced on Reddit amidst other accusations against the 90 Day Fiancé star. Meanwhile, Vanessa, who Steven was dating for only three or four months exposed him by revealing that he was sleeping with three women during his trip to Russia. “I know divorce is so difficult; you made these vows to him. But I don’t think he’s going to change,” Vanessa told Steven’s wife Alina.
But Alina claims Steven who is “fully invested” in their marriage will hopefully change his behavior because he truly loves her. In fact screenshots of the dirty chats that Steven had with the nine women were also shared with Alina, who seems to have stayed unbothered despite it all. As per a 90 Day Fiancé YouTube clip, Alina also didn’t blink an eye when Steven looked towards Evelin, who was joining the Tell-All taping from a screen with husband Corey Rathgeber, and told her, “Evelin, I think this is the most modest I’ve ever seen you dressed.” When Steven’s 90 Day Fiancé: The Other Way cast members felt their jaws drop, he continued, “no, it’s just a fact,” and all an embarrassed Evelin could do was look downwards and mutter, “Oh my God.” Fans clearly aren’t happy about Steven’s latest red flag and bashed him online, like in this Reddit thread by u/AshtonKechamall.
“He has the maturity and social filter of a toddler, and is simultaneously a predator,” wrote u/PICKLEPARTY2024. “Lol him of all people talking about modesty. Throw the whole man away,” posted u/FullOfMelanin and u/imtryingmyhardest_ observed, “He’s so socially inappropriate you have to wonder what is going on in his head.” However, a few also happened to criticize Corey for letting Steven say something like this about his wife and not shut him down for it. But fans really can’t seem to understand how Steven thinks he can get away with making comments that are either nonsensical or in this case, highly tasteless on national TV.
On the other hand, Evelin was praised by 90 Day Fiancé: The Other Way viewers for the classy way in which she complimented Ariela Weinberg. A cheerful Evelin said that Ari’s dress was “killer” and called her the hottest girl on the Tell-All set. While Evelin has almost always received flack for her actions and edit from TLC viewers, she can never compete with the wrath that is coming Steven’s way after the Tell-All airs. Fans who still wish for Alina to dump Steven are seemingly hoping they never get to see him in the franchise again.